Smoking Cessation Therapy May Be Harmful For ICU Patients
10/27/06
A common smoking cessation
therapy used to help reduce adverse events associated with nicotine
withdrawal may actually increase the risk of death for smokers admitted to
the intensive care unit (ICU). In a new study presented at CHEST 2006, the
"In some critically ill patients, the development of nicotine
withdrawal symptoms can worsen their prognosis. As a result, NRT is given
to active smokers in the ICU to prevent nicotine withdrawal symptoms," said
lead researcher Amy Lee, MD, Mayo Clinic College of Medicine, Minneapolis,
MN. "The hemodynamic effects of nicotine may lead to increased heart rate,
systemic arterial blood pressure, and constriction of the coronary
arteries. Although these potential adverse effects of NRT have not been
shown to worsen the prognosis of healthy volunteers and patients with
stable coronary artery disease, they may be detrimental in critically ill
patients."
Lee and colleagues examined the safety of NRT in the ICU by reviewing
the medical records of 112 smoking patients admitted to the ICU who
received NRT during their stay. Researchers compared patient outcomes
between the NRT group and a control group. Among the patients who received
NRT, 18 deaths (16.1%) occurred, compared with the 3 deaths (2.7%) in the
control group. The hospital mortality rate was 21.4% for the NRT group,
compared with 5.4% in the control group. Furthermore, when researchers
controlled for severity of illness, NRT was found to be an independent risk
factor for mortality (odds ratio 17.0).
There were no statistically significant differences in age, gender,
ethnicity, and severity of illness measured by APACHE III prognostic model
between the NRT and control groups. The median ICU length of stay for the
NRT group was 24.4 (16.1 - 63.6) hours, compared with 22.6 (14.0 - 42.8)
hours for the control group. The median hospital length of stay was 29.6
(18.3 - 127.1) hours, compared with 46.2 (19.8 - 117.3) hours for the
control group.
"Although administering nicotine replacement therapy to smokers in the
ICU is not a standard practice, some ICUs have nurse-driven protocols aimed
at providing NRT for active smokers. We expect NRT to be more widely used
in such ICUs," said senior author Bekele Afessa, MD, FCCP, Mayo Clinic
College of Medicine. Common signs of nicotine withdrawal include craving,
irritability, depression, restlessness, and sleep disturbances. However,
researchers caution that, because of other conditions that mimic nicotine
withdrawal in the critically ill, it may be difficult to make an accurate
diagnosis.
"Minimizing the effects of nicotine withdrawal in critically ill
patients who smoke can present a significant challenge to the ICU team,"
said Mark J. Rosen, MD, FCCP, President of the American College of Chest
Physicians. "The findings of this study are intriguing and reinforce the
need for additional research regarding the effects of nicotine replacement
therapy on patients in the ICU."
CHEST 2006 is the 72nd annual international scientific assembly of the
American College of Chest Physicians, held October 21-26 in Salt Lake City,
UT. ACCP represents 16,500 members who provide clinical respiratory,
critical care, sleep, and cardiothoracic patient care in the United States
and throughout the world. The ACCP's mission is to promote the prevention
and treatment of diseases of the chest through leadership, education,
research, and communication. For more information about the ACCP, please
visit the ACCP Web site at